sunrise over Gatlinburg, Tennessee

5 Best Pizza Places in Pigeon Forge You Have to Try

johnny carinos
October 12, 2021

If you begin craving a warm, cheesy pizza, you don’t have to look far in Pigeon Forge. There are tons of places that offer some incredible slices that’ll leave you coming back for more. Whether you like to keep it simple with just cheese and pepperoni or you like to pile on the toppings, you will find a pizza that you love in the Smokies. Here are the 5 best pizza places in Pigeon Forge you have to try:

1. Johnny Carino’s

For all your favorite Italian specialities, you have to check out Johnny Carino’s! While their pasta, seafood and Italian platters are all fantastic, the handcrafted pizzas are what draw people in. Their homemade dough cooked to perfection in a wood-burning oven is just the start of their attention to detail in their pizza pies. If you’re a meat lover, you’ve come to the right place. Try the Pepperoni and Pepperoni or Johnny’s Three-Meat Combo for layers of juicy meats on top of great sauces and soft crust. We can also suggest the Traditional Margherita with tomato sauce, roma tomatoes, mozzarella, parmesan and fresh basil.

2. Big Daddy’s Pizzeria

bid daddy

With locations in Pigeon Forge, Gatlinburg and Sevierville, you’re never too far from a Big Daddy's Pizzeria when you visit the Smoky Mountains. Their wood-fired brick oven pizzas keep people coming back year after year. Not only do they offer classics like a traditional cheese pizza and the Boo Boo Bomber (pepperoni pizza), they also have delicious specialty pies. We suggest the Big Kahuna, Chicken Florentine or Smoky Mountain Cheesesteak. If none of those options are what you’re looking for, you can build your own pizza! With so many options, it’s no wonder Big Daddy’s is one of the best pizza places in Pigeon Forge!

3. Marco’s Pizza

While there is nothing like a warm slice of pizza, Marco’s is changing the game with their Pizza Bowls. Enjoy all of your favorite pizza toppings and flavors without the crust. At Marco’s Pizza, you can build your own bowl or choose from their menu, including options like All Meat, Deluxe and Garden. If you’d rather keep it classic, their traditional pizzas are just as good and come in a variety of options.

4. Mellow Mushroom

mellow mushroom

With an amazing selection of stone-baked pizza pies, Mellow Mushroom is a fan favorite for pizza lovers in the Smokies. Hand-crafted and baked to order since 1974, Mellow Mushroom has been turning out mouth watering slices for over 45 years. When you stop in today, you’ll have tons of options to choose from, including the Great White, Backyard BBQ, Holy Shitake Pie and more! If you’re gluten free, they have a whole menu of pies made specifically for you! We recommend trying the Kosmic Karma or Mighty Meat.

5. Geno’s Pizza

Family owned and operated since 1984, Geno’s Pizza is a Smoky Mountain staple! Serving the freshest ingredients to locals and visitors alike, Geno’s is considered one of the best pizza places in Pigeon Forge and Gatlinburg. After you try their pizza pies, you’ll know exactly why they’ve been voted Best Local Pizza multiple times. Some fan favorite options include BBQ Chicken and Bacon, Steak and Cheese and the Vegetarian Special.

Now that you know where to find the best pizza places in Pigeon Forge, you’ll know exactly where to go when you get to craving this Italian classic. Are you looking for more fun things to do in the area on your Smokies vacation? Check out all the exciting activities and attractions near our hotel in Gatlinburg and begin planning your next trip. We look forward to seeing you!